Will Shadow of the Erdtree Be the 2024 GOTY? Fans Are Furious About the DLC's Nominations
Elden Ring Continues to Dominate the Gaming World
From Software's latest masterpiece, Elden Ring, continues to dominate the gaming world, with its recent nominations for the 2024 Game of the Year (GOTY) awards causing quite a stir among fans. However, the nominations have also sparked controversy, as many fans are expressing their outrage over the inclusion of the game's upcoming DLC, Shadow of the Erdtree, in the GOTY race.
Fans Express Disappointment Over DLC Inclusion
Many fans have taken to social media to voice their disappointment over the DLC's inclusion in the GOTY nominations, arguing that it is unfair to pit an expansion against complete games. They believe that DLCs should be judged separately from base games, as they offer a different type of gaming experience.
Some fans have also expressed concern that the DLC's inclusion could set a precedent for future GOTY awards, opening the door for other incomplete games to be nominated. They argue that this could lead to a devaluation of the GOTY award and make it less meaningful.
Critics Defend Nominations, Cite Quality of DLC
Despite the backlash from fans, critics have defended the DLC's inclusion, citing its exceptional quality. They argue that Shadow of the Erdtree is not just a minor expansion, but a substantial addition to the Elden Ring experience that rivals the quality of the base game.
They also point out that DLCs have been nominated for GOTY awards in the past, such as The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine, which won the award in 2016. Critics argue that if a DLC is of sufficient quality, it deserves to be recognized alongside complete games.
Will Shadow of the Erdtree Win GOTY?
Whether or not Shadow of the Erdtree will ultimately win the 2024 GOTY award remains to be seen. The competition is fierce, with other highly acclaimed games such as The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom and Starfield also in the running.
However, the DLC's inclusion in the nominations is a testament to its exceptional quality and the continued dominance of Elden Ring in the gaming world. Regardless of whether it wins GOTY, Shadow of the Erdtree is sure to be one of the most talked-about games of 2024.
Conclusion
The controversy surrounding Shadow of the Erdtree's GOTY nominations highlights the ongoing debate about the place of DLCs in gaming awards. While some fans believe that DLCs should be judged separately from complete games, others argue that they deserve recognition for their exceptional quality.
Ultimately, it is up to the judges to decide whether or not Shadow of the Erdtree is worthy of the GOTY award. However, regardless of the outcome, the DLC's inclusion in the nominations is a testament to the continued success of Elden Ring and the exceptional quality of From Software's latest creation.
